Look, I love a good awards-show meltdown as much as anyone. But The Game Awards 2022 was a different breed of fever dream. We got an eight-minute acceptance speech right out of the gate. We got a stage-crasher during Elden Ring's Game of the Year speech who somehow wasn't instantly launched into the sun. And we got the Players' Voice category turning into a full-blown fandom cage match between Genshin Impact and Sonic Frontiers. It's 2026, and awards season has already given us fresh material—Crimson Desert just took PC Game of the Year at the 2026 Golden Joystick Awards—but I still keep circling back to that 2022 mess. Honestly? It remains the most bizarre award-show subplot I've ever covered.

the-players-voice-war-was-the-messiest-part-of-the-game-awards-image-0

The setup was almost wholesome. Players' Voice is the 100% fan-voted category, the one where the audience gets to shout into the void and sometimes get a trophy out of it. Sonic Frontiers fans wanted recognition for a game they loved, especially since it earned zero juror nominations across any category. Genshin Impact fans, meanwhile, showed up with the kind of numbers you'd expect from a community boasting around 60 million active players. Sonic Frontiers actually led the first two rounds, with Genshin following closely behind. At that point, it looked like a fun little rivalry. Then round three happened, and the internet sharpened its pitchforks.

That's when the accusations started flying. Sonic fans accused Genshin fans of being bribed to vote. Genshin fans pointed out that artwork of Sonic characters beating the stuffing out of Genshin characters had begun circulating during a Chinese day of mourning, which spurred a wave of mass voting. There were also accusations of racist or xenophobic remarks aimed at Genshin players. Reddit posts were made, fingers were pointed, and lifelong virtual rivalries were formed over a category many of us lovingly call the most pointless award of the night. Elden Ring? Irrelevant. Never heard of it. God of War Ragnarok? Who is she? Stray, Minecraft, Sifu, MultiVersus, Cult of the Lamb—nothing but collateral damage in the war between waifus and speedy hedgehogs.

Fandom What they wanted What they got
Sonic Frontiers Recognition after zero juror nominations An early vote lead, then a locked subreddit
Genshin Impact A fan-voted win for a massive community The trophy, plus bot accusations

By the time Geoff Keighley took the stage, the whole thing had become a bit of an awkward elephant in the room. He laughed through the nominees for the '100% fan-voted category' and added, 'you guys were very busy voting the past few days.' Then he threw in a sly jab at the bot accusations, all but confirming some foul play had taken place: 'Once we took out all the bot votes, the game award goes to Genshin Impact.' The vote counter was probably sweating through its circuits. Genshin Impact won. The Sonic community, to put it mildly, did not take it well.

At the time, the Sonic subreddit hunkered down fast. Mods cleaned up toxic posts and comments, and many of the top threads were locked. Genshin fans, meanwhile, teased the Sonic community for allegedly starting the whole beef, claiming the blue blur would've taken the crown if fans had stayed quiet. That's it. That's the drama. A fan-voted award turned into a proxy war, and nobody looked especially great by the end of it.

Now, I'm a fence-sitter. I've played and enjoyed Genshin Impact. I've played and enjoyed Sonic games. I can barely pick a pair of socks in the morning, let alone side with one of two equally frightening fan bases. But it's a shame to see two clearly passionate groups going at each other in increasingly mean ways. The Game Awards—and especially the Players' Voice vote—are supposed to be a bit of fun at the end of the day. I'm sure plenty of fans cross over into both communities and won't appreciate the ongoing beef. It's locked now, but I hope the nice artwork of Sonic and Lumine hanging out will remind people why we love these games in the first place.

So yeah, the trophy went to Genshin Impact, but the real prize was the arguments we made along the way. Except no—please don't do that again, buddy. Awards season in 2026 has enough chaos already.